An Interesting Acknowledgement By Federal Reserve Governor, Jeremy C. Stein
The fact of the matter is that the fundamentals of “crowdfunding” are not new. In fact, the practice has been around for decades. That said, the recent rise of real estate crowdfunding platforms has generated equally strong opinions by supporters and critics.
Jeremy C. Stein, the Federal Reserve Governor recently addressed the topic during a speech in Washington, D.C. We find Mr. Stein’s thoughts to be interesting and worthy of sharing with our community. Here’s the speech in its entirety:
Acknowledged by Governor Jeremy C. Stein
At the Crowdfunding for Community Development Finance Conference, Washington, D.C.
Good morning. Let me start by welcoming everyone to the Federal Reserve. Today’s topic of crowdfunding for community development finance is an important and topical one. And, I want to thank you all for helping us think through the challenges and opportunities presented by this new technology. Especially, as it relates to raising funds for local communities.
This gathering is particularly timely for two reasons. First, in many communities, traditional resources for community development are shrinking. Additionally, the field is actively seeking to identify new sources of funding. Second, the Securities and Exchange Commission recently released its proposed rule under the Jumpstart Our Business Startups–or JOBS–Act. This is likely to influence the environment for crowdfunding in general and for community development finance specifically.
Crowdfunding Continues to Expand
To the extent that most people know about crowdfunding at all, they may associate it with tech startups or independent movie production. Since the press coverage has often focused on examples in these areas. These stories typically describe the use, and often successful, of crowdfunding, as aspiring inventors and artists. As they are able to tap the Internet to raise the money that can help make their visions a reality.
The question for today is whether this power of the crowd can be harnessed to support community development, a field. One that has not widely benefitted from crowdfunding thus far. Indeed, when I say “power of the crowd,” it is worth noting that while individual investment amounts may be small, the total amount of funds raised from this source can be large. Although we lack reliable data on the current size of crowdfunding, some sources indicate that it’s a multibillion-dollar industry. Currently, with more than 1 million separate offerings each year. Even more so, that the field is growing rapidly.
Learning From What Works
While crowdfunding may not be as well known in the community development context, there are, in fact, existing models of crowdfunding for community development that we can learn from. I understand that several of these existing models will be discussed on a panel later this morning. One local example is Fundrise, an investment platform for commercial real estate that gives individuals the opportunity to invest directly in neighborhood businesses. Fundrise started on the H Street corridor here in D.C., and has completed 18 real estate deals totaling more than $10 million.
For example, this platform attracted 361 people to invest a total of $350,000 toward the redevelopment of 906 H Street, N.E. Currently a vacant building, this property is located on the quickly revitalizing H Street corridor. Now, has the funding necessary to renovate the property and transform it into a restaurant or retail space.
The Calvert Foundation’s Community Investment Note Example
This is an interesting one because Calvert Foundation was essentially doing something akin to crowdfunding for community development before Internet platforms became available. As you may know, Calvert Foundation is a certified Community Development Financial Institution (CDFI) that was established in 1988 as a 501(c)3. Due to, Calvert Investments finding a strong interest among its clients to invest directly in underserved communities.
Since 1995, 13,000 people have invested in these notes, which provide a financial return while economically empowering communities.2 According to Calvert Foundation, these 13,000 individual investments have collectively helped to create 430,000 jobs for low-income individuals, built or rehabilitated 17,000 affordable homes, and financed close to 26,000 nonprofit facilities and social enterprises.3 Both the Fundrise and Calvert Foundation examples hint at the potential of scaling up crowdfunding for community development.
What’s interest does the Fed have in this topic?
First, at a fundamental level, it’s important for us to keep our finger on the pulse of financial innovation and the changing dynamics of the financial services industry–even in those parts of the industry where we do not have a direct regulatory role. We know that financial innovation can offer both opportunities and pitfalls; by carefully and even-handedly studying each new product or service at an early stage in its lifecycle. Additionally, we can hope to better understand both the potential benefits, as well as any risks for adverse impacts on households and communities.
Also, through convening like today’s event and by sharing promising practices, the Federal Reserve System has a longstanding history of supporting local and regional community and economic development efforts that contribute to economic growth and employment. To the extent that crowdfunding has the potential to bring new capital into low- and moderate-income communities, we want to be involved in helping the learning process along.
Continuing Growth Expected
As I mentioned earlier, many people associate crowdfunding with tech startups and art initiatives. However, there are ways that the community of development investing adopts this new form of fundraising. Given how wide open the issues are, today’s event is a working meeting with discussion groups. We appreciate your willingness to share your time with us, and we look forward to benefitting from your insights.